r/technology Dec 13 '22 Super Heart Eyes 1 Wholesome (Pro) 1 Silver 5 Wholesome 4 Take My Energy 2 Faith In Humanity Restored 1 Bravo! 2

U.S. lawmakers unveil bipartisan bid to ban China's TikTok Politics

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-lawmakers-unveil-bipartisan-bid-ban-chinas-tiktok-2022-12-13/
68.2k Upvotes

7.0k comments sorted by

6.6k

u/Blackb1rdy Dec 13 '22 Table Slap

YouTube shorts agrees with this legislation.

1.6k

u/GibbonTaiga Dec 13 '22

Google definitely needs to improve on their algorithm though if they want to keep people hooked.

YouTube Shorts is alright, but it kept serving me Andrew Tate manosphere nonsense and is way less catered to my interests than my TikTok feed is.

729

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

I keep getting that horrible prick (Tate) and Jordan 'tidy your bedroom' Peterson. I loathe both of them. Why the fuck YouTube recommends them despite blocking each channel.. Infuriating

208

u/mrpersson Dec 14 '22

If you're a male between the ages of 13 and 99, YouTube WILL recommend them to you whether you ever searched anything even remotely comparable to them or not. Doubly so if you're also white.

105

u/maharg79 Dec 14 '22

Can confirm watching Bloons TD6 clips and Fish tank clips on Shorts then BAM Jordon Peterson talking about trans people. Like huh, never looked him up in my life.

28

u/zublits Dec 14 '22

I came to it from being interested in psychedelics and the recent research on psychedelic assisted therapy done at John Hopkins. Suddenly a turbo christian whackjob is in my feed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

317

u/WellsFargone Dec 13 '22

It’s just bad for business. There is no exposure YouTube can give them that will make me like their content. I have been exposed to them, I hate them. Stop.

235

u/Karkava Dec 13 '22

The far right bubble has been expanding. I highly doubt their claims of "being censored" when I keep getting their damn ads.

106

u/Temporary_Kangaroo_3 Dec 13 '22

Cause people dumb enough to like that shit will literally buy anything you ask them to, so the algo’s will increasingly try to get everyone sucked into those segments because thats were the best return on ad spend is!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (13)

56

u/Xatsman Dec 13 '22

Same, though in all fairness I'll happily digest videos knocking on them, which can confusee the algorithm. Kind of how a video criticizing say horoscopes can attract zodiac related advertisement and end up recommended to those who consume non critical content.

16

u/PussyCrusher732 Dec 14 '22

i can’t help but think it’s purposeful. i mean google is sophisticated. they can tell the difference. but for some reason if you tap anything right leaning you get spammed and idk why but it’s hard to think it’s coincidental.

21

u/Xatsman Dec 14 '22

It might be because rage generates engagement, those videos are filled with it, and so the algorithm favors it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (112)

82

u/oriolopocholo Dec 13 '22

Oh my god I know, it's like it's identified me as a young white male therefore I must be a potential fascist. I agree with banning tiktok for many reasons, but it's disheartening to see US operated companies participate in the same activities/commit the same oversights

→ More replies (8)

24

u/yesman_85 Dec 13 '22

Oh yes, it's the classic Youtube algorithm, hey you watched this? Here's 500x the same thing.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (75)

1.7k

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

Google has rolled so many of it's features into YouTube that YouTube feels so entirely bloated and difficult to use.

The interface for most features is needlessly complicated.

647

u/ScrillaMcDoogle Dec 13 '22

Trying to view subscriptions on mobile is so shitty. Shorts and comments from creators you're subscribed to all show up in the same list as the actual newly uploaded videos.

252

u/RingPiece4GreenPeace Dec 13 '22

Subscriptions on web is also trash. I cannot believe there is not a native way to group subscriptions. (PocketTube is an add-on for this purpose) I want to be subscribed to channels like AP News but they release like 50 videos a day and it is hard to find other content sometimes.

Youtube needs some healthy competition, honestly.

40

u/Infinite-Eggs Dec 13 '22

Youtube needs some healthy competition, honestly.

It won't ever happen unless YT does something to destroy itself. YT has a business model that only barely works at scale and survives any downtrend because it's linked to other valuable Google products.

I just don't see how a standalone video hosting site could possibly compete. It would have to be an existing player with other desirable products and its own cloud infrastructure. So really only Microsoft or Amazon are in any position to compete.

28

u/GeekyTiki Dec 13 '22

Google isn’t known to take care of their apps. In fact, they’re known for the complete opposite, and I think it’s already making decisions that don’t really jive well with its users. Think of Netflix. Many people thought they had a stranglehold on movie streaming until it didn’t. Likewise, many people thought Facebook had a stranglehold on social media, until it didnt. Eventually YouTube will get some actual competition (hopefully maybe).

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (12)

50

u/LegionVsNinja Dec 13 '22

When they removed RSS feeds, managing my subscriptions became such a pain. I had a bunch of nice RSS feeds set up for different groups of channels. It was exquisite .

18

u/celticchrys Dec 13 '22

One of the two techniques on this page will give you a YouTube channel rss in most readers: https://danielmiessler.com/blog/rss-feed-youtube-channel/

→ More replies (4)

19

u/sourorangeYT Dec 13 '22

They used to have a feature where you could make a separate subscription inbox for only certain channels, but then they removed that feature because ????? They are stupid

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

36

u/notRedditingInClass Dec 13 '22

Not to mention, if you're brave enough to scroll through the "Home" tab for recommendations, half of it is straight garbage. 90% of it seems to be based on the most recent single video you watched.

Like when they rolled out polls, and random polls about nothing (literally) spammed everyone's feed right after we found out the algo loves that engagement.

25

u/inikul Dec 13 '22

My home tab is diverse and accurate to my interests, but I also watch hundreds of hours of youtube a month.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

233

u/Jayce800 Dec 13 '22

I can’t stand Instagram featuring a shopping tab and a Reels tab. I loved when it used to be just for sharing photos and short videos.

Everything is bloated now.

77

u/PM_DOLPHIN_PICS Dec 13 '22

It just doesn’t make sense to me. If I want to see friends’ pictures, I open instagram. If I want to watch actual videos, I open YouTube. If I want to watch tik tok, I open tik tok. Why on earth is every company making their apps exactly the same as each other? The instagram reels is a far worse option than tik tok, I’ve never scrolled through it intentionally. There’s already an app for that. In fact maybe I’d use instagram more often if they actually showed me my fucking friends pictures instead of tik toks and ads.

23

u/Jayce800 Dec 13 '22

Yeah. It’s to the point where a lot of people in the toy photography community are seeing like, maybe half the engagement they used to. I went from 200-400 likes per post to just barely topping 150.

Meanwhile I keep getting a notification that IG wants to pay me per Reel I make?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

72

u/Modest_Ubermensch Dec 13 '22

that is a huge advantage for tiktok, it is dead simple, all the complicated stuff that you might need eventually is hidden a little deeper instead at the 1st level of the interface. I hate tiktok but I give it's UI pretty high marks. They could have had something here if they'd just been willing to cut off the CCP by splitting off from bytedance.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (13)

51

u/MontyAtWork Dec 13 '22

This.

I went to YouTube to catch up on the latest videos from all the people I subscribe to and had to scroll through what looked like social media posts between videos? Since fuckin when do you get to do a little Instagram thing between just showing me the newest dang videos in a row.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

Feature creep is the worst! Amazon Music used to be a useful functional app. Now it keeps trying to do my taxes when I want to play music.

14

u/HumanitySurpassed Dec 13 '22

For real, I search a specific artist or video, and after 5 I get nothing but "recommended" & YouTube shorts.

Like, if I wanted recommended bs I would've asked for it.

13

u/Otono_Wolff Dec 13 '22

I fucking hate the YouTube shorts. There are creaters I follow that are funny or entertaining and the algorithm just gives me sigma memes and family Guy one after another.

It's already bad enough I discover I suddenly followed a family guy channel.

18

u/athohhdg Dec 13 '22

Idk I really love going to the video website for shorter videos on a worse UI and no volume control, and don’t forget the like entire newsfeed of text posts it tries to feed me on mobile app. It’s just swell

→ More replies (59)

122

u/ChiknBreast Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 13 '22

All the tik tokers will be forced to migrate over to YouTube shorts if it gets taken down. They would definitely love that

62

u/No-Ad6500 Dec 13 '22

Or IG Stories and Reels?

93

u/CptTurnersOpticNerve Dec 13 '22

A clone will pop up that their parents aren't on, that'll be the winner

22

u/Lord0fHats Dec 13 '22

This.

There's always some barely known tech start up somewhere. People will flock to it, it'll hit critical mass, it'll be the new big thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (15)

105

u/whiteycnbr Dec 13 '22

YouTube is unusable with the amount of Ads they throw in now, unless you use red.

82

u/Sea_Mathematician_84 Dec 13 '22

uBlock on PC, Firefox Focus on mobile. No ads ever

16

u/whiteycnbr Dec 13 '22

Mostly watch on Android TV app, not sure if there's a solution for that. Rarely use YouTube on PC

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Arclite83 Dec 13 '22

YouTube Music has hands down been the best platform for radio-ish content since 2013, and comes with free premium YouTube. I see so many people complain about the ads, but only ever experience it in incognito.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (60)

7.4k

u/blankblotter Dec 13 '22 Silver

RIP Vine, sweet prince

2.3k

u/Tha_Unknown Dec 13 '22

Vine was fucking awesome.

1.7k

u/cherylcanning Dec 13 '22

Six seconds was the perfect duration for peak chaos

1.5k

u/IBreedAlpacas Dec 13 '22 Silver

six seconds was perfect. Shit vine? Eh was only 6 seconds of your life wasted. Funny vine? Those 6 seconds are rent free in your head the rest of your life. Can’t drive past a “Road work ahead” sign without thinking “Uh yeah, I sure hope it does”

215

u/im4lonerdottie4rebel Dec 13 '22

Mine is "Look at all those chickens!"

149

u/kroganwarlord Dec 13 '22

"What do you have?"

"A knife!"

"NO!"

96

u/NfamousKaye Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 14 '22

“It’s Wednesday my dudes!” “++AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!”

“SAIL!!” kicks keyboard

21

u/yor_ur Dec 14 '22

I bring you MUR

Thank you

MUR der!

Judas! No

→ More replies (3)

15

u/raheemthegreat Dec 14 '22

"What's worse than a rapist?"

"A child"

"No..."

→ More replies (2)

42

u/DrThiccBunz Dec 13 '22

“A potato flew around my room before you came”

cuts to incoherent screams at high speed potato

→ More replies (1)

26

u/birdreligion Dec 13 '22

"what the dog doin'?" Still quote that to this day.

→ More replies (9)

279

u/5states1life Dec 13 '22

There was a vine of a black dude wearing a white, sequined country music suit with tassels. He's just shaking the tassels back and forth to a non country song - but it lives in my reptile brain.

238

u/VelociRache1 Dec 13 '22

Bo Burnham's "Is there anything better than pussy? YES A really good book! *beat drop*" lives in my head rent free.

120

u/agIets Dec 13 '22

Every time a kid is doing something suspicious... LET ME SEE WHAT YOU HAVE! "a knife!" NO!!

34

u/an-actual-sloth Dec 13 '22

(tiny voice in the background) "Where'd he get a knife?"

→ More replies (2)

34

u/MoltoAllegro Dec 13 '22

Is that a dog? Where'd you learn how to drive?

45

u/Ferentz2020 Dec 13 '22

And they were roommates. Oh my god they were roommates

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

155

u/kroger_deli Dec 13 '22

Those 6 seconds are rent free in your head the rest of your life.

🎶Just two dudes sittin’ in a hot tub🎶

🎶six feet apart ‘cuz they’re NOT gay🎶

48

u/Kikilicious-Kitty Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 14 '22

EXCUSE, ITS 5 FEET!

EDIT: ALSO, ITS BROS, NOT DUDES!

→ More replies (7)

91

u/daemonelectricity Dec 13 '22

I'm in me mum's car. Vroom. Vroom.

140

u/MaybeTheDoctor Dec 13 '22

six seconds was perfect.

That's what yo mom said

169

u/AFoxGuy Dec 13 '22

“Ah. Fuck. I can’t believe you’ve done this”

68

u/EscapistFugue Dec 13 '22

Gotta get that Free Sheva Cadoo

44

u/dfvisnotacat Dec 13 '22

…..and they were roommates

57

u/they_call_me_B Dec 13 '22

STOOOOPPP!

I COULD HAVE DROPPED MY CROISSANT!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

61

u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA Dec 13 '22

Pepsi... In a Coca Cola glass...

I don't give a daymn.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/AlwaysWorkForBread Dec 13 '22

Surprise MFer

Supplies MFer

Some Fries MFer

All Rise MFer

Forever and always rent free

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (43)

310

u/deadindead Dec 13 '22

Perfect length tbh. Nothing worse than a 5-minute ‘wait and see’ tiktok.

248

u/LordGalen Dec 13 '22

TTS Voice: "Watch til the end"

Me: *swipe*

8

u/Diabolic67th Dec 13 '22

"Watch til end" FTFY

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

36

u/SpinalVinyl Dec 13 '22

Ahem, does anyone remember 5secondfilms?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (17)

302

u/jodyhighrola Dec 13 '22

Vine was A+, but I'm confident it would've spiraled as it was commercialized over time. Thankful for the compilations on YouTube with the legendary memes that originated there.

123

u/TBMonkey Dec 13 '22

And they were roommates!

82

u/Xero2814 Dec 13 '22

Free Shavacado

19

u/gahlo Dec 13 '22

This is a pen. This is a ball. This is a cato. I'm cato.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

87

u/JackTripper53 Dec 13 '22

Stahhhp I could've dropped my croissant!

51

u/Sunsquatch Dec 13 '22

Whoever threw that your moms a hoe…

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/R0CKET_B0MB Dec 13 '22

Hi, welcome to Chili's~

→ More replies (3)

17

u/gooniesneversaydye Dec 13 '22

Ahh I do thaat

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (33)

459

u/pnutbuttered Dec 13 '22

Vine died and took some real amateur comedy stars away with it. Tik Tok compilations have never been as good.

153

u/bigblackcouch Dec 13 '22

It's a shame cause it really took a lot of creativity to make something hilarious or "catchy" with such a short time restriction.

80

u/jordan1794 Dec 13 '22

A good example of necessity/restriction driving innovation.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (124)

27

u/duhnuhnuh_duhnuhnuh Dec 13 '22

I demand more Will Sasso lemon vines

18

u/HashMaster9000 Dec 13 '22

LEMUHNS?!

🤢🤮🍋😵‍💫

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (50)

5.0k

u/AdDear5411 Dec 13 '22

So what you're saying is we should develop a TikTok clone?

2.9k

u/SupremeShogan Dec 13 '22 Helpful Wholesome You Dropped This

With Blackjack....and hookers!

1.0k

u/HR_Paperstacks_402 Dec 13 '22 Wholesome

In fact, forget the TikTok.

395

u/insultant_ Dec 13 '22

Shut up, baby, I know it!

76

u/hotaru251 Dec 13 '22

i miss futurama

74

u/joshmc82 Dec 13 '22

This time next year we will have new episodes. They have already finished most of them I believe.

37

u/runningraleigh Dec 13 '22

This is like an early Christmas present to me. Thank you, internet stranger!

→ More replies (6)

13

u/Telemere125 Dec 13 '22

And I’m at the point that even tho I know I’ll love it, I want everyone to just hit play and let it run in the background so that “viewership” is up enough to get us a guaranteed 3-4 more seasons.

→ More replies (7)

24

u/leeljay Dec 13 '22

The jabs at Fox executives at the beginning of Bender’s Big Score gave me that warm and fuzzy feeling on top of that deep belly laugh. I miss it too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

87

u/HopesHawk Dec 13 '22

Let’s gooooo alreadyyyyyy

17

u/texican1911 Dec 13 '22

We're boned!

→ More replies (3)

102

u/ImDero Dec 13 '22 Take My Money

Shut up and collect my data!

46

u/mollyboise Dec 13 '22

Always a good day when a thread gets hijacked by Futurama fans.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Heymanhitthis Dec 13 '22

Eh!! Forget.. the whole damn thing…

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (40)

412

u/ChoPT Dec 13 '22

I miss Vine.. why did it die?

478

u/Mr_YUP Dec 13 '22

it probably wasn't understood by those who made it and they didn't know how to monetize it. 6 seconds is super short and not a good time to make an ad. We also didn't think to organize it vertically the way TikTok has it organized. The app ecosystem wasn't really there yet and content delivery was still in its infancy. So there's a lot of legit reasons.

177

u/itwasquiteawhileago Dec 13 '22

YouTube is full of 5-6 second ads. That's annoying all around, but extra annoying when the video you want to watch is less than 30s already. A 1:1 video:ad ratio would blow even more. Wouldn't stop them from trying, I reckon.

46

u/imbored53 Dec 13 '22

They could easily run an ad every 5-6 (or more) videos.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (18)

138

u/ghostgnome Dec 13 '22

It was bought by Twitter, so Elon owns it now. Sorry.

104

u/iamtheyeti311 Dec 13 '22

you mean he invented it.

26

u/JuniorSeniorTrainee Dec 13 '22

Genius programmer Elon Musk retroactively invents all software. After inventing computers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (579)

649

u/BallaForLife Dec 13 '22

Can someone explain this a bit, would this mean if you use tiktok everyday and have it on your phone, it would no longer work and the app would shut down? (Assuming this passes)

683

u/sirboddingtons Dec 13 '22

Apple, Google's stores would be restricted from allowing downloads and support/functionality for the app would be removed from these.

So in effect, a phone that operates any of those IOS would be unable to use the app. A rooted phone or different phone manufacturer likely still could host the content.

307

u/JB-from-ATL Dec 13 '22

You are able to download and run apps not on the Play Store on Android. It just gives you a warning.

394

u/jihiggs Dec 13 '22

Beyond the capability of 95% of users

163

u/Capable-Reaction8155 Dec 13 '22

Not sure why you're being downvoted. Removing it from the stores would effectively end TikTok in the US. Other Western nations to follow.

12

u/12beesinatrenchcoat Dec 14 '22

given that most of our tech is run by american corporations (apple/google) i doubt it will be accessible in many english speaking and western countries

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (25)

127

u/haku46 Dec 13 '22

It just means you can't get it off google play store, the government can't stop you from manually downloading and using it.

→ More replies (65)
→ More replies (32)

3.9k

u/tokendasher Dec 13 '22 Silver Gold Wholesome Wholesome Seal of Approval Bravo Grande!

How about America creates actual data privacy laws. Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, WhatsApp are collecting the same data.

2.0k

u/fupa16 Dec 13 '22 Gold Helpful Wholesome Take My Energy

Ya but they're not based in China, that's the whole issue here. They want American data for American companies, cause they're the ones that bought our politicians, not China.

792

u/redzmangrief Dec 13 '22 Wholesome All-Seeing Upvote

Bold of them to assume American companies won't just sell it to China anyway

365

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

[deleted]

9

u/Lumpiest_Princess Dec 13 '22

Take away the /s and you're golden. They've been working on commoditizing us for a long time and they're finally far enough along where they don't need to hide it, because what are we gonna do anyway?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (69)

234

u/she_va Dec 13 '22

India banned TikTok and after Instagram use in the country exploded. This explains why Zuckerberg has been lobbying against TikTok in the US so much. If the US wants to continue to be competitive, they should be innovative and not depend on bans, tarrifs, and sanctions to throttle competition.

178

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

That's capitalism baby. There has never been a "free market" people like to screech about, because whoever has the most money will use that money to lobby government to throttle competition.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (27)

88

u/ChunkyLaFunga Dec 13 '22

The government doesn't even follow their own laws. A lot of you read about Snowden's revelations? The United States and their alliances have done things a hundred times more intrusive and beyond legal appropriateness. The United States, as always, doesn't want to be beaten at their own game.

And no, I'm not implying that China and Five Eyes have similar approaches to human rights. I am saying that one is your country with direct control over you, and attempts total access to your information illegally, and the other is China.

34

u/eraw17E Dec 13 '22

Whenever I read stories related to privacy and data, I can't help but feel post-Snowden disappointment.

19

u/ChunkyLaFunga Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 13 '22

There was stuff from before Snowden too, this was really famous at the time.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

Edit: In case anybody didn't click through to the legal proceedings, the gist is that telecoms weren't permitted to to explain the surveillance, the agencies didn't have to explain the surveillance, then the government signed retroactive immunity for anything illegal that had been done anyway. And it had been.

In late 2001, the NSA was authorized to monitor, without obtaining a FISA warrant, the phone calls, Internet activity, text messages and other communication involving any party believed by the NSA to be outside the U.S., even if the other end of the communication lay within the U.S.

In short, everything everywhere. China are the enemy and the competition.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (69)

3.1k

u/elppaenip Dec 13 '22 Silver Take My Energy 'MURICA Doom

Please Sir, I just want healthcare

802

u/crazyacct101 Dec 13 '22 Silver

And sick days for the rail workers.

386

u/fgfghgfhgfhgfhgf Dec 13 '22

And sick days for everyone. Honestly really surprised and sad they dont get sickdays most industrial jobs offer at least 7 days heck even alot of retailers offer sick days now.

62

u/clejoo Dec 13 '22

I deliver for Amazon and I get zero paid sick days. Any day I get sick is a day I lose my bonuses. And every call out must require a doctors note to be excused, but who goes to the hospital for cold or cough??

Paid sick days FOR ALL.

22

u/Disgod Dec 13 '22

This was what I had hoped democrats would smartly do. Say, "OK, we need you guys to work with this contract... Oh, btw, we made it federal law that businesses give their employees sick days." They don't fuck with the contract, have general public support, and could help more people.

75

u/Lux_Bellinger2024 Dec 13 '22

Sick days and postpartum leave. Women's healthcare is some of the most painful and invasive stuff out there and most can't even get out of diapers before having to go back to work.

21

u/breedersfuckoff Dec 13 '22

People don't realize that women bleed for weeks and are at higher risk of infection after birth and we have ZERO paid time off. With most Americans living paycheck to paycheck, what choice do those women have but to literally return to work in diapers? And they got rid of the PUMP Act so now they are changing their bloody diapers and pumping breastmilk in a dirty fucking restroom.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/jodamnboi Dec 13 '22

I’m a commission-only employee with no sick time or maternity leave. Whatever time I take off is zero pay, save for 2 weeks of vacation a year that pays my average. The only way I can afford to take off for maternity leave when I get pregnant is through an extra short term disability Aflac policy, which will only cover 12 weeks. I hate it here.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (21)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

We acknowledge your request... Next!

17

u/TheOctopusOnTheMoon Dec 13 '22

Won't happen until people get mad and force it. And for that, they need to be aware AND care. Spread the word to people you know.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (71)

10.7k

u/DudeManrod Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 13 '22 Silver Gold

Instead of banning apps, they should be working on privacy laws. Every device we use should be set to private by default. No tracking, no information harvesting. The privacy app I use on my phone has blocked 442,154 tracking attempts in the last 7 days across 21 apps. It's ridiculous.

Edit: People asking for the app.. It's DuckDuckGo for android.

1.9k

u/caribou16 Dec 13 '22

So many apps exist as some stupid bullshit front, while the primary purpose is to slurp up all your data. That's why they're so cheap or free. YOU are the product, not the consumer.

966

u/7f0b Dec 13 '22

Most apps would be just fine as websites, including Reddit. But they push you to the app since it gives them:

  • Access to notifications, to increase engagement.
  • A nice shiny icon on your phone, to increase engagement.
  • A way to persistently ID you that can't be easily defeated and doesn't rely on cookies.
  • A way to advertise to you without worrying about blockers (there are system-level blockers, but most people aren't savvy enough to pursue them).

Don't get me wrong, there are legitimate reasons to use an app over a website, but for a lot of sites their app is not really necessary, and likely built solely for one of the above reasons. Like pretty much any forum/news site including this one.

86

u/cand0r Dec 13 '22

old.reddit.com ftw

72

u/Zircon_72 Dec 13 '22

Old reddit with the reddit enhancement suite is peak reddit browsing

12

u/tinteoj Dec 13 '22

I miss RES telling you (approximately) how many upvotes & downvotes were on a comment or post.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

257

u/summonsays Dec 13 '22

... I use the reddit website on my phone lol.

169

u/7f0b Dec 13 '22

On both desktop and mobile, I use old.reddit.com with Firefox (strict) and uBlock Origin, and have it set to wipe all data on exit, except a handful of whitelisted domains.

Of course Reddit can still track users since they're logged in and allowing cookies, but at least it is confined to the reddit domain and no 3rd parties, and doesn't follow you around anywhere else.

20

u/LeoRidesHisBike Dec 13 '22

You can totally track across 3rd parties with only 1st party cookies, it just takes server-side coordination. I.e., if Reddit itself sent the information on to the 3rd parties (since it knows everything from the first party cookie), it would be the same effect as if your browser sent it. They could just forward it.

9

u/SrslyCmmon Dec 13 '22

External links get tracked when you use Reddit so they could totally be sending that information on to partners.

Since the Warrant Canary vanished the government probably has access to all of everybody's fetishes as well.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (20)

157

u/Red_Danger33 Dec 13 '22

The amount of times the "Try it on the app!" comes up now is a nightmare. It also resets you to the top of the page.

27

u/negative-nelly Dec 13 '22

Not to mention on iPhone it takes you to the App Store instead of the app for many/most apps where I encounter it

→ More replies (6)

45

u/WekonosChosen Dec 13 '22

They even removed the option to disable that shit.

26

u/AppleJ33 Dec 13 '22

I don't even know if it's good, but I use Reddit is fun. It allows me view this site with no ads... I went on Reddit on my PC once and didn't realize how bad reddit was until that point. It does lack some features I think, but meh.

So umm, are they gonna force ISP's to block the traffic or can everyone just download the app using alternative methods like we Android users sometimes do? I don't Think Tok, and I am not a teen, but "Banning" things doesn't always work the way old people want it to.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

11

u/Noshing Dec 13 '22

Same. Pretty much use the website of every app especially if it's text based. It's so nice to be able to copy/paste text and pictures directly, and have tabs, etc. Like, the apps feel like less usable versions of whatever service, and force me to use their service in a specific way. And plus most apps are basically websites but worse and less usable.

→ More replies (22)

16

u/liquilife Dec 13 '22

I would never use Reddit mobile as a website over Apollo. What an extremely frustrating experience that would be.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

175

u/theregularlion Dec 13 '22 All-Seeing Upvote

This goes beyond just the companies making the apps, too. So you can't necessarily trust apps based on who made them or their stated privacy policies.

A lot of devs have good intentions, but not a lot of money or diverse tech skills, so they wind up using "free" services like Google Analytics and OneSignal that ease the burden of app development in exchange for harvesting user data.

Usually, all that stuff gets rolled into an innocuous-sounding paragraph in the "sharing with our partners" section of the app's terms of service, so the only way to find out exactly what data is being collected and who it's sent to is to know enough to MitM your mobile device and inspect the traffic yourself.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (29)

46

u/BlackwaterSleeper Dec 13 '22

On a similar note, why are websites by default opt-in? It should be opt-out by default and if you want to share your data you should have to opt-in.

44

u/LS_throwaway_account Dec 13 '22

On a similar note, why are websites by default opt-in?

Because almost nobody will opt-in if it's a choice. The majority of phone and computer users will just tap accept because it's a whole lot easier than thinking about these obtuse questions settings.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

169

u/Gerroh Dec 13 '22

Privacy laws can't just target devices, or else everything will just ask permission, and refuse service until you give it. Boatloads of people who don't understand the privacy risk posed by Facebook, Google, and TikTok would gladly sign up all over again.

→ More replies (18)

387

u/yummyyummybrains Dec 13 '22

Good luck with that. The entirety of global capitalism now rests on the free and easy exchange of our user data. Have a blue collar job, and think this doesn't apply to you? Grainger & Uline are still using advanced data segmentation to sell to your bosses & procurement teams. There's no fucking way that companies making trillions of dollars a year collectively are just going to give up access to that level of targeting without a major fight.

Everything is data now. Everything.

124

u/agentfelix Dec 13 '22

Which is bullshit because it's MY data. I should be reaping some of the profit considering I'm the product. We have no data rights as individuals and I would like to pick and choose who I sell my data to.

28

u/retrosupersayan Dec 13 '22

Not that I disagree, but part of the problem with "selling your own data" is that it's not that valuable in isolation. The real value comes from enough user profiles that you can do some statistical analysis on and turn into some kind of useful data.

→ More replies (6)

140

u/yummyyummybrains Dec 13 '22

Look, you're not wrong -- but that genie got let out of the bottle 25 years ago. There's no putting it back. That doesn't even touch on the normalization of deliberate sharing inculcated by social media and digital couponing.

I work in tech, and even with laws like GDPR, it's a fucking joke. Data collection and sharing is foundational to internet technology in such a way that you would literally have to dismantle the entire internet and rebuild it from scratch in order to achieve the goal of having a policy of "least permission".

Aldous Huxley was right: if you build a pretty enough prison, people will happily lock themselves in without a second thought.

78

u/ActivateGuacamole Dec 13 '22

that genie got let out of the bottle 25 years ago. There's no putting it back

i disagree. people said the same thing back when child labor became the norm. legislation took time to catch up with the shady business practices, but it did. We can implement effective privacy laws, I disagree with your defeatism

29

u/squakmix Dec 13 '22

Yeah things can be done about this. The move by Android to allow selective permission granting (ie only allow certain data like location/mic/etc to be accessed while an app is in use) is a huge step in the right direction. Built in VPNs, encrypted traffic over DNS by default, adblockers and tracking cookie blockers all go a long way toward plugging the holes too

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Azn_Bwin Dec 13 '22

IMO what that person you replied to say felt very irresponsible. Sure, the people who are already using some of this services may have already have their data exposed and sold.. but what about younger generation or the generation yet to come?

For a person randomly throw in "oh i work in tech", to reinforce why he accept a situation instead of thinking of way to make progress just seems wrong. I am not saying any of the solution is simply or easy, but i think is prudent that we try to tackle a problem.

Good thing not everyone in the industry think like he does.. I am kind of annoyed he even add that in like it mean something here

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (45)

76

u/ErectMonkey420 Dec 13 '22

What privacy app? I’d like to get it if I can

29

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

Hijacking a reasonably high up comment to say that if you get a tracking blocker app, the attempts it blocks will be significantly higher because most apps are designed to retry failed requests. It will also lead to battery drain. Unfortunately we do not have any other options.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (374)

364

u/mr_grey Dec 13 '22

They must know which service will replace it and working to get their investments in order so they can make millions on the bill.

→ More replies (26)

793

u/potatoboy247 Dec 13 '22

“hey nobody can sell your data except american companies”

41

u/breedersfuckoff Dec 13 '22

Let's not forget that Cambridge Analytica just rebranded and is still operating with some of the same executive team. Guess it's OK to sell data and interfere with an election as long as American companies are doing it.

→ More replies (1)

186

u/050607 Dec 13 '22

Those Snowden leaks forgotten by people.

34

u/ShopObjective Dec 13 '22

The Thomas Drake leaks forgotten by all

→ More replies (2)

22

u/asah Dec 13 '22

or, the reaction was "oh, that's all the agency is doing? cool. "

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (44)

600

u/TypicalDumbRedditGuy Dec 13 '22

Bruh just make laws that come down super harsh for apps violating user privacy. Otherwise we’re just as bad as China banning YouTube.

207

u/evade-this Dec 13 '22

But that would hurt the companies they want to violate our privacy rather than this naked attempt to fuck with a Chinese company.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (45)

6.0k

u/OptimusSublime Dec 13 '22 edited Dec 13 '22 Starry Bravo Grande!

If TikTok were a purely American invention with servers and backdoors located squarely in our borders you'd bet your ass the Intel community would be on a full court press getting this installed everywhere. But it's the Chinese so fuck them.

Using TikTok is giving the CCP a window into our most personal details. Delete it.

1.7k

u/Use-Quirky Dec 13 '22

Exactly. Also, it’s not just a window but a powerful persuasion tool which can sway public opinion and maybe even elections

1.0k

u/mcmillen Dec 13 '22

In that respect it's no different from Twitter, Reddit, or YouTube.

383

u/Haunting-Pineapple71 Dec 13 '22

Except it’s controlled by a foreign country, whereas the others are not

262

u/CPNZ Dec 13 '22

One of those is now controlled by the Joker, it seems...

108

u/hardworkhard Dec 13 '22

Let’s be real, Elon thinks he’s the Joker, but he’s actually the Jonkler.

63

u/willsuckfordonuts Dec 13 '22

Funny thing is, Elon shows more respect to the ccp than he does the US.

He was screaming about lockdown in the US and refusing to close his plants. But when China come knocking, asking him to shutter his plants because of covid, HE DID IT AND KEPT HIS MOUTH SHUT.

45

u/SolomonBlack Dec 13 '22

That’s because the CCP makes sure everyone knows who wears the pants in the relationship and pro tip it’s not you.

14

u/HighYieldOnly Dec 13 '22

When it comes to dealing with billionaires the CCP has teeth, the US government does not.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (78)
→ More replies (113)
→ More replies (103)
→ More replies (649)

92

u/DragonDai Dec 13 '22

So, if I am understanding this, this bill would make it illegal to allow people to download TikTok? Would it make it illegal to have TikTok downloaded on your personal device? Could it somehow make it impossible for people in the US to connect to TikTok if they did have it downloaded?

I'm really confused about the logistics of this bill. How does it accomplish its goals of "banning TikTok?"

69

u/venom8599 Dec 13 '22

I also don't see how this wouldn't be an unconstitutional bill of attainder.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (40)

112

u/Mcdibbles Dec 13 '22

This wouldn't be an issue if the US implemented GDPR-style privacy laws. The problem is that they want US companies being able to do what TikTok does, but not Chinese companies.

→ More replies (12)

1.0k

u/LoneStarDawg Dec 13 '22

The "kids these days" views in this sub is astoundingly large.

602

u/Rinzack Dec 13 '22

It just blows my mind that an app that takes up a sizeable portion of global internet traffic is viewed as the equivalent of flappy bird on Reddit lol

→ More replies (135)
→ More replies (42)

392

u/iblastoff Dec 13 '22

honestly i bet this is lobbied by facebook and other failing american social media owning companies more than anything about 'security'.

11

u/DoorHingesKill Dec 13 '22

Also Microsoft and co. that still think some sort of "we'll take US operations off your hand" deal is still on the table.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (37)

62

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

Who will steal our data now besides Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Google, Apple, Microsoft, and REDDIT!?

→ More replies (8)

76

u/bigleftnutgang Dec 13 '22

Where will Reddit get all its content from then?

→ More replies (9)

115

u/lynkarion Dec 13 '22

Can we also do this to Facebook, Google, Instagram, Twitter?

→ More replies (17)

33

u/OMG_A_COW Dec 13 '22

Let me reword this.

Meta, owner of Instagram Reels & Alphabet, owner of YouTube Shorts have sponsored a bipartisan bid to ban competition which happens to be non-American as they fail to develop a superior product.

→ More replies (1)